Research Proposal - Can an ‘interactional’ account of philosophical human rights be a tool for attributing responsibility for global structural injustice?

This project investigates whether two important concepts in political philosophy are compatible - 'interactional human rights' (i.e. human rights derived from basic moral principles, not international law), and 'structural injustices' (unjust harms caused by social structures, not by individuals).
Like

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the shortened URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

Summary of research:

Part of the job of human rights theorists in political philosophy is to decide which harms against individuals should count as human rights violations (HRVs). ‘Structural injustices’ are harms which we have reason to call unjust, but which are caused by complex social structures such that it is difficult or impossible to consider any one individual responsible for them. This research intends to investigate whether it is conceptually coherent to describe some of these structural injustices as HRVs.

 This project works within one specific theoretical understanding of human rights – the ‘interactional’ account. On this account, each right is held by one individual, against another individual (i.e. the other individual has a duty to respect that right). The tension between this account and the concept of structural injustice is that when the interactional account is being used to name HRVs, it relies on identifying responsible individuals. The hypothesis I will test is that there are at least some types of structural injustice in which these harms can be considered HRVs (on the interactional account).

The motivation for this research is primarily to demonstrate to structural injustice theorists that interactional human rights can be taken seriously as a way of attributing moral responsibility for structural injustices.

Please sign in

If you are a registered user on Laidlaw Scholars Network, please sign in