Project Outline - Rhetoric or Responsiveness: The Effect of Local-Campaigning on Electoral Success and Parliamentary Behaviour

Rhetoric or Responsiveness: The Effect of Local-Campaigning on Electoral Success and Parliamentary Behaviour
Research Advisor: Dr. André Turcotte
Abstract
This research explores how local-centric election campaigns influence both electoral outcomes and subsequent parliamentary behaviour in first-past-the-post (FPTP) democracies. Using the 2024 UK General Election as a case study, where the Liberal Democrats increased their seat count by 650% on just a 0.6-point rise in vote share, the project examines whether riding-targeted campaigning does more than win elections: does it also reshape representation? While local campaign tactics have been studied for their strategic utility, little is known about their impact once candidates become legislators. This study proposes to fill that gap by quantitatively measuring the “localness” of campaigns, using variables such as spending patterns, local messaging, and candidate background, and examining their relationship to both electoral success and MP responsiveness. Drawing on the distinction between party loyalists and constituency MPs, the research will evaluate whether local campaigners act more independently and advocate more for their ridings in Parliament. This research relies on linear regression analysis to measure the impacts of these variables and control for others. Beyond the UK, this work has broader implications for understanding representation in FPTP systems globally, from Canada to India. Ultimately, the project seeks to shift the conversation from rhetorical appeals to measurable responsiveness, providing a new lens on democratic accountability in an age of democratic upheaval.
Background
Like many engaged citizens, driving change deeply interests me, particularly through grassroots power, which political parties increasingly harness for electoral success. As both a student of political science and a practitioner with Pollara Strategic Insights, campaign strategy fascinates me, not just as a tool for winning elections, but for its broader impact on how Members of Parliament represent us.
Research shows that constituency-level efforts, especially by smaller parties like the Liberal Democrats in the UK, can significantly shift electoral outcomes. This reached a zenith in 2024, where the Liberal Democrats, campaigning on a “local champion” strategy, increased their seat count by 650% on just a 5% (0.6 point) rise in vote share. Studies on electoral success through local campaigning, particularly on the Liberal Democrats, have largely focused on the mechanics of grassroots activism,4 the role of constituency targeting in marginal seats, the effects of campaign spending on vote share,6 the broader strategic advantages of continuous campaigning, and the party’s ability to convert local presence into electoral gains.
While much attention has been given to how local campaigns shape elections, far less is known about whether they change how MPs behave once in office. Some research suggests that politicians with strong local ties are more independent-minded and responsive to their constituents. If voters are being persuaded by local campaigns, it becomes essential to know whether that campaign rhetoric translates into substantive representation. MPs represent their constituents in Parliament; this study aims to understand campaign strategies impacts on parliamentary behaviour, constituent representation, and democratic governance itself.
Methodology
- Conduct a literature review on first-past-the-post elections, especially as it relates to electoral efficiency (the translation of votes into seats) and theories of representation.
- Develop a quantitative measure of the “localness” and riding-targeted nature of campaigns.
- Proposed metrics include i) ad spending concentrations ii) other spending concentrations, iii) the proportion of website material that discusses local rather than national issues, iv) local council presence and v) other relevant metrics publicly available after conducting further research.
- Use regression analysis in SPSS to measure the effect of local campaigning on electoral outcome.
- Drawing on the distinction between party loyalist and constituency MPs, develop a quantitative measure of non-party responsiveness in Parliament.
- I will control for confounding variables including historical petition activity by riding as well as party size, and MP role, among others, for all metrics.
5. Use regression analysis in SPSS to measure the effect of local campaigning on parliamentary behaviour.
6. Write a research paper discussing the findings from the above-noted analysis and situating it within the relevant literature. I also aim to explore the findings’ applicability to other first-past-the-post countries.
Potential Impact
I see this research as having a variety of outcomes:
From an academic perspective, a substantial literature is devoted to local campaigns and their effect on voter behaviour. I aim to open a new field on how local campaigns affect subsequent parliamentary behaviour. More broadly, I hope to spur academic research into how campaign strategy impacts various facets of democracy beyond a simple rhetoric-discourse analysis.
For citizens, when we as voters see a candidate who claims to represent us, and will fight for local interests in Parliament, should we believe them or is it simply a campaign tactic?
The findings of the proposed study from the UK apply most to other first-past-the-post systems across four continents. By engaging with scholars who study these systems in countries like India, I hope to deepen international understanding.
Centuries ago, the parliamentary tradition birthed Representative Democracy, then in the 1800s, Responsible Government truly vested sovereignty in the people. Part of my mission is to finally help move democracies towards Responsive Government. This analysis aims to define and measure some of the preliminary metrics that might lead to reforms in that direction.
Please sign in
If you are a registered user on Laidlaw Scholars Network, please sign in